MARATHON FINISHING SYSTEMS

Paint booth recirculation in cure mode: how 80/20 saves gas and where it stops

ยท Marathon Finishing Systems

Isometric drawing of a heated spray booth with exhaust stacks

Paint booth recirculation, in the 80/20 form we quote, sends about 80 percent of a heated booth's air back to the heater in cure mode and brings in about 20 percent fresh air. The burner reheats air that is already warm instead of starting from the weather, so it burns less gas.

A heated booth burns gas for one reason: it has to warm outside air. Cure mode is where that use climbs, because the booth is working toward bake temperature with the doors shut. Marathon Finishing Systems, a spray booth manufacturer in Temecula, California, offers 80/20 as an upgrade. It changes what the heater has to warm and not much else, and it has limits you should know before you ask for it on a quote. This post covers cure mode only.

A quick look at the three modes

A heated Marathon booth runs its heater in three modes: prep, spray and cure. Prep runs at about half of the spray air while the painter masks and sands. Spray runs full design airflow of fresh, filtered outside air. Cure runs with the booth empty and the doors closed. We walk through all three in our post on the three modes of a booth heater, so we won't repeat it here. What matters for this post is the third one. In cure, nobody is inside, and that is when the 80/20 upgrade returns air to the heater.

What does 80/20 recirculation do in cure mode?

With the 80/20 upgrade, a motorized damper changes the air path. About 80 percent of the booth air goes back to the heater. About 20 percent is fresh air from outside. The burner is reheating air that is already warm instead of starting from the weather. The bake is the same. There is just a lot less cold air to heat.

Without recirculation, cure mode is once-through. Every bit of air the heater puts into the booth comes from outdoors, passes the part and leaves through the stack. The burner has to lift all of that air from outdoor temperature up toward bake temperature, then you throw it away.

Why does recirculation save more gas in cold climates?

Cold climates gain most because the gas a heater burns tracks the gap between the air going in and the temperature you want. On a mild day that gap is small and there is not much to save. On a hard winter morning the gap is wide. Once-through, the burner has to cover all of it on every pound of air. With recirculation, most of the air is already near bake temperature after the first few minutes, so the burner only has to cover the wide gap on a fifth of it and top up the rest.

There is a second benefit that has nothing to do with gas use. Every heater has a limit on how much temperature rise it can make in one pass. On a cold day, a once-through cure at full airflow can ask for more rise than the unit can give, and the booth never gets to temperature. Recirculation lets the same heater reach bake temperature on days it otherwise would not.

We won't print a savings number. It depends on your gas rate, your winter, how many cure cycles you run and how long each one lasts. A shop that cures a few times a day in a mild climate will see a small gain. A truck or equipment shop in a cold state running back-to-back cures will see a lot. Our sales team can walk through your cure schedule and climate with you.

For the wider view of heater type, booth size and controls, see our post on energy efficiency in industrial finishing.

Where it stops

80/20 recirculation is an upgrade, not standard. A heated booth without it is a complete booth, and many run well without it. We quote it on supported booth and heater combinations, and the drafting team engineers the duct package and dampers for the job. Tell us early, because it is drawn into the duct package. We prefer to do it when the heater is booth mounted or roof mounted. Long duct runs between the heater and the booth lose too much heat to make it worth it.

It needs heat, so on our indoor spray booth families it goes on the heated ones: Reverse Flow, Semi Downdraft (we call it Modified Down Draft), Side Down Draft and Full Down Draft. Front Flow and Open Face cannot take a heater, so they cannot take recirculation either. Semi Downdraft is not a true down draft, and the recirculation package follows the heater, not the name.

It runs in cure mode only, with no painters in the booth. The cure cycle is interlocked to the doors, and the controls include a booth purge. The details are settled at drafting.

It does not shorten your cure time by itself. Bake time is set by your coating and your part temperature. Recirculation changes what it costs to get there and whether a cold day gets in the way.

It is not a fix for a leaky building or a badly sized heater. If the booth cannot hold temperature because of the air coming in from the shop, we would look at that first.

Can a recirculating paint booth use any heater?

No. Not every heater can recirculate. A direct-fired heater used on a spray booth is built to run on outside air. Returning air through the burner is a different duty, and the heater has to be listed for it. For cure-only recirculation, that means a heater built to ANSI Z83.25, the standard for direct gas-fired process air heaters, which allows recirculation in the bake and dry stage with the booth empty. If a quote does not name what the heater is rated for, ask.

The controls matter as much as the heater. The damper, the door interlock and the purge are settled at drafting so the panel matches the booth and the heater. A recirculating booth is also quoted with a gas detection kit tied to the fans.

Your local AHJ has the final word on what it will accept. In California, confirm cure-mode recirculation with your AHJ and Cal/OSHA before you count on it. Permits and fire suppression stay with the owner. Marathon does not do either, but we can give you the documentation your inspector will want, available upon request.

Extreme Air Agitation is a different upgrade

People mix these two up. Extreme Air Agitation is its own upgrade for heated booths. It moves heated air around inside the booth through nozzles in the gables, for even temperature across the part and fast drying with waterborne and solvent paints. It does not change how much air comes in from outside or goes out the stack. Recirculation changes how much air the burner has to heat. Agitation changes how the heated air moves. Some shops want one, some want both, and plenty want neither. The right answer comes from your coating and your cure schedule.

Is paint booth recirculation worth asking for?

If you cure often, live in a cold climate, or run a big booth that holds a lot of air, it is worth a serious look. If you cure once a day somewhere mild, probably not. Either way, the answer should come from your own hours and climate, not from a percentage in a brochure.

How many cure cycles is your booth running a day, and what does your coldest month look like? Send us the part and the building, or hop on a call and we'll walk through it with you.

FAQ

What is 80/20 recirculation in cure mode?

80/20 recirculation is an upgrade for heated booths. In cure mode, with the booth empty and the doors closed, about 80 percent of the booth air is returned through the heater and about 20 percent is fresh outside air. The burner reheats air that is already warm, so it burns less gas than a once-through cure.

Is 80/20 recirculation standard on a Marathon heated booth?

No. 80/20 recirculation is an upgrade, not standard, and a heated booth without it is a complete booth. We quote it on supported booth and heater combinations, and the drafting team engineers the duct package and dampers for the job. Tell us early so it gets drawn in.

Can any booth get 80/20 recirculation?

No. A booth needs a heater for 80/20 recirculation, and heat is not available on Front Flow or Open Face booths. On our indoor spray booths it goes on Reverse Flow, Semi Downdraft, Side Down Draft and Full Down Draft booths. Semi Downdraft is not a true down draft, and the recirculation package follows the heater, not the name.

Does 80/20 recirculation run while someone is painting?

80/20 recirculation as we quote it is a cure-mode upgrade, run with the booth empty and the doors closed. Recirculating while someone paints is something we typically do not recommend, but we can do it depending on the circumstances. The details are settled at drafting.

Will 80/20 recirculation shorten my cure time?

No. 80/20 recirculation does not shorten cure time by itself, because bake time is set by your coating and your part temperature. Recirculation changes what it costs to get there and whether a cold day gets in the way. It also lets the same heater reach bake temperature on days it otherwise would not.

What is the difference between 80/20 recirculation and Extreme Air Agitation?

Recirculation changes how much outside air the heater has to warm. Extreme Air Agitation is a separate upgrade that moves heated air around inside the booth through nozzles for even temperature and faster drying. Neither one is standard. Some shops want one, some want both, and plenty want neither.